What media bias looks like…

May 14th, 2008 John McG

Posted in media |

On my igoogle home page, I have widget that publishes “STLToday.com Top News Headlines.”  Current entries, as of 12:20 today:

The first item is an editorial criticizing the Missouri state legislature for delaying on a health care bill.

Now, I have a very hard time believing that these are the three most newsworthy stories the St. Louis Post-Dispatch is covering right now.  The first is an opinion piece, the second presents a one-sided view of an issue, the third is an announcement for a typical spring/summer event.

This feeds into my post below.  Is it a huge crime crying out for vengeance that the Post-Dispatch would choose these as its “top” headlines?  I suppose not.  But it erodes my confidence that what they tell me is important truly is.

AddThis Social Bookmark Button

Odd Headline of the Day…

February 29th, 2008 John McG

Posted in media, baseball |

“Juan Gone welcomes Santana to the NL”

What’s wrong with this?

  1. Spring training games are interleague, so that Santans’s first spring training start was against another NL team was just a 50/50 shot.
  2. Juan Gonzalez had spent his entire career in the American League.
  3. Gonzalez’s position for this game?  Designated Hitter

I’m not sure getting a home run hit off you by a career AL player in the DH slot in a sping training game is really an apt intro to the National League.

AddThis Social Bookmark Button

Who’s the star?

November 28th, 2007 John McG

Posted in media, politics |

The advertising for tonight’s YouTube debate among the Republican candidates prominently notes that Anderson Cooper will be the moderator. This is consistent with how the advertising of the Las Veas Democratic debate featured Wolf Blitzer.

It strikes me as akin to promoting the World Series with a picture of Joe Buck.  The promotion of Cooper for tonight’s debate seems especially odd since the questions are submitted by video.

Tim Russert came in for some criticism after Senator Clinton fumbled his driver’s license question, but from that to Chris Mattews’s “raise your hand” evolution question, it does seem like the debates are increasingly more about allowing the reporters to make a name for themselves than the candidates.

I mean, does anybody remember who moderated the famous Nixon-Kennedy debate?  Was Walter Cronkite’s home town common knowledge?

Bernard Shaw made himself famous asking Michael Dukakis if he would favor the death penalty for the murderer of his family.  It seems that today’s moderators are similarly swinging for the fences, hoping for a “gotcha” YouTube moment, with unlikable results.

AddThis Social Bookmark Button

Green Is Universal (Just for this week)

November 5th, 2007 John McG

Posted in global warming, media |

NBC turning the lights off in the studio during the halftime and postgame shows during last night’s game is quite possibly the stupidest stunt I have ever seen.

If you didn’t catch it, they went through the ususal halftime in the dark while they all (including lefty Keith Olbermann) chuckled about how silly it was for them to be doing a TV broadcast from a darkened studio, and how this was a one-week only thing. Costas noted some statistic that by doing this, they were saving enough energy to power a typical household for a month. (I don’t remember the exact figure and can’t find it now)

This is like “raising awareness” about obesity by having John Madden fast for a day, complaining about his hunger the entire time.

Let’s consider the lessons being sent here, shall we?

  • Conservation requires draconian non-susatainable measures.
  • Your impact is negligible

Sorry, knowing that our household’s entire energy consumption for a month doesn’t add up to what it takes to ensure we see every one of Chris Collinsworth’s pores just during one week’s halftiume and postgame shows isn’t going to get me to jump out of the shower quicker to save the planet.

And is NBC considering any other actions to reduce the consumption? I mean, them having to play an extra game every week at night so that NBC has an exclusive time slot must add to consumption, right? Have they considered forgoing halftime and postgame studio shows and letting Michaels & Madden handle it? Do they really need five people in the studio for a ten minute halftime show?

Yes, they can’t possibly cut back there. But I better not linger too long in the shower. Right.

Then they interview Matt Lauer from the North Pole.

Now. The “hypocrisy” angle of environmentalists gets overblown. You have to spend money to make money, and you need to travel and use technology in order to spread the environmental gospel. I get that.

So let’s assume that sending Matt Lauer and a production crew to the North Pole, and Ann Currie and another production crew to Antarctica is a net gain for the environment because they raise our “awareness,” and we all start biking to work.

Even if that’s the case, the involvement of Lauer is a reminder of this:

For what has become one of Today’s trademark series for the past six years, Lauer has broadcast live from remote locations around the world for the “Where in the World is Matt Lauer” annual trip. His trips have taken him to over 25 different locations, logging over 146,000 miles. In the spring of 1998, Lauer reported from the Great Pyramids in Egypt, the Grand Canal in Venice, the Parthenon in Athens, the Taj Mahal in India and the Sydney Opera House in Australia. In 1999, his week-long adventure took him to Mount Everest, aboard the U.S.S. Theodore Roosevelt stationed in the Adriatic Sea, to the Coliseum in Rome and to the Great Wall of China. In 2000 he covered more than 39,000 miles, stopping at the Kilauea volcano in Hilo, Hawaii, Bilbao, Spain, Victoria Falls, Zimbabwe, Pisa and Florence in Italy and Iceland. For the 2001 trip, his stops included Machu Pichu, Peru, an oil rig off the coast of Scotland, Paris, Bangkok and Mykonos, Greece. 2002 found Lauer in Rio, Scotland, an escape in the Amazon, Marrakech/Rose City, the temples of Angkor Wat and jet-setting in Monaco. Most recently, in 2004, he reported from a Mombo Camp in Botswana, on the alps of Zermatt, Switzerland, the Red Square in Moscow, Hong Kong and Necker Island: Sir Richard Branson’s private island.

For the last several years, NBC has sent Matt Lauer and a production crew on a trip to five places scattered around the globe pretty muich for the hell (pun intended) of it. You think that might be a bigger deal than my double bagging? Is NBC cancelling this year’s Matt Lauer trip? Not bloody likely.

I know, I know. None of this changes the ecological reality, and if this causes some change in behavior, it’ll all be worth it. But there’s still something wrong with someone sitting at a feast to lecture me that I shouldn’t be eating my cracker.

AddThis Social Bookmark Button